Butter Poached Lobster Tail Recipe

Butter Poached Lobster Tail Recipe

The small lobster tails at my local grocery store were on a super sale so I could not help but get a couple. Seems like such a luxury item when you are not in New England, but when on sale, I could not resist! I decided to poach them in butter like they do in restaurants because it really is good. Here is a fabulous lobster tail recipe!

Level of Difficulty: Moderate Time Required: Prep Time – 10 min; Cook Time – 7 min


2 uncooked lobster tails, removed from shell

1 stick of butter, cut into cubes

2T water

salt and pepper

If you want a long and silly video of how to kill a lobster humanely – check this out. Fast forward to about minute 7 for the actual way to do it. We got a little carried away with ourselves!

Preparing Butter Poached Lobster Tail Recipe:

I had two small lobster tails and poaching them in one stick of butter was enough. You’ll need enough liquid that the tails are submersed in the butter (or beurre monté as it is called in fancy French cooking circles).

how to cook lobster

Here are my two small uncooked lobster tails. You’ll want to remove them from their shells and cut them partially down the center to clean out the vein.

lobster tails

How to make Beure Monte for lobster tail recipe:

Place 2T of water in a sauce pan over medium high heat to bring to a boil. Then, with a whisk, add one small cube of butter at a time while constantly whisking. Once it is melted, add another cube of butter until you’ve slowly incorporated the entire stick. Don’t stop whisking. This will emulsify the butter so that it does not separate like normal melted butter does between its fats and solids. Don’t let the butter boil as it will break apart.

lobster on the stove

Once the butter is all melted, add the lobster tails.

lobster tails

Using a spoon, keep the beurre monté over the lobster tails. You’ll do this until the tails are cooked through which will only take about 7 minutes.

lobster tails

That’s it! Sprinkle with a bit of salt and fresh cracked black pepper and enjoy.

Important Tips:

Add the butter slowly, keep whisking and don’t let it boil. Lastly, don’t overcook the lobster.

It’s not a complete waste of butter as you can reuse it. Just place the leftovers in an airtight container and keep in the fridge. You can reuse it for another lobster tail or to sauté something like shrimp scampi.

3 thoughts on “Butter Poached Lobster Tail Recipe”

    • It is evidently a fantastic lobster season so they keep having great sales. I found them at Publix but even more recently they were buy one get one. There is an Asian market in Chamblee somewhere that sells the big ones for around $5 all the time but I haven’t been yet.

      • If you go 285 to Buford Hwy, turn left and it is up on the hill where the old Richway Department Store used to be (just told my age). Great meat department as well with super prices.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.